Remarkably, he was found guilty again because the prosecution claimed that Staker had consensual sex with someone else that night… even though she was only 11 years old! On August 17, 1992, an 11-year old girl named Holly Staker was raped and murdered while babysitting in Waukegan, Illinois. However, the Norfolk Four remained incarcerated since police still maintained that they acted as Ballard’s accomplices. It would be 16 years before new DNA testing was done and it wound up matching Steven Cunningham, a convicted inmate who was serving time for another murder and subsequently confessed to killing Correa. In 2005, DNA tests excluded Rivera as the perpetrator and he was granted a third trial. 9 High-profile crimes, such as the Lindbergh kidnapping in the 1930s, the Black Dahlia murder in the 1940s, and the JonBenet Ramsey and Nicole Brown Simpson murders in the 1990s, tend … The Central Park Five were all tried and found guilty and given sentences ranging from five to thirteen years. They would soon be convicted of the crime and in January 1993, John Purvis was finally released after serving nine years. 1.1. The Supreme Court has long emphasized that “admissions and confessions of juveniles require special caution.”. A person may, for example, provide a voluntary false confession out of a desire to aid and protect the real criminal, 35 to provide an alibi for a different crime or norm violation, 36 or to get revenge on another person. (pause) We know, we just need you to tell us. Some have been Supreme Court cases. ... classified known false confession cases into three categories. Coerced-compliant false confessions are those in which a suspect confesses to police in order to escape an aversive interrogation, avoid an explicit or implied threat, or gain a promised or implied reward. The details about the murder were clearly fed to him and he seemed unaware of what he was doing when entering his plea in court. A vulnerable, intellectually disabled juvenile is unlikely to accurately or voluntarily confess. False confession cases always result from the way that an interrogation has taken place. Brendan: That’s all I can remember. One of the most common interrogation methods used by … Lying by interrogators, which occurs in virtually all false confession cases, should be strictly limited. Beginning with the Salem witch trials of 1692, numerous false confessions surfaced when it was later discovered that the confessed crime had not been committed (e.g., the alleged victim turned up alive) or that it was physically impossible (e.g., the confessor was demonstrably elsewhere) or when the real perpetrator was apprehended (e.g., by ballistics evidence). Officer: All right, I’m just gonna come out and ask you. Saipan at the time of the murder. Dassey confessed to murdering a woman, in association with his uncle, after being questioned by police four times over a period of 48 hours. Juveniles are extremely vulnerable to pressure. False confessions can be categorized into three general types, as outlined by American Saul Kassin in an article for Current Directions in Psychological Science: Voluntary false confessions are those that are given freely, without police prompting. Brandon Garrett is the Justice Thurgood Marshall Distinguished Professor of Law at the University of Virginia School of Law. In 1996, Johnny Lee Wilson was finally granted a pardon by Missouri governor Mel Carnahan and released after serving nine years. They told him key facts — including the central piece of physical evidence they had gathered: that the victim had been shot in the head. His exoneration, over 20 years later, would never have occurred. Like the Juan Rivera case, prosecution pushed the theory that the victim had consensual sex with someone else before she was murdered. The legal standard for an involuntary confession is whether law enforcement officers used tactics that undermined the suspect’s ability to exercise free will. He was threatened and intimidated by police during his interrogation and thought he would be allowed to go home if he confessed. 7 Voluntary False Confession – a false confession knowingly given in response to little or no police pressure. The classic case of an involuntary confession is a police officer questioning a suspect who is in pain and in the intensive care unit after suffering serious injuries; the officer continues the interrogation despite the defendant’s request for an attorney. She was killed in her home in Boulder, Colorado, in 1996. Voluntary False Confessions . But false confessions are fairly common. He eventually came to believe the police’s assertion that he had blacked out and forgotten he committed the murder, so he signed a confession. The West Memphis Three were soon charged and found guilty of the murders, with Echols being sentenced to death. The popular Netflix documentary Making a Murderer told a compelling story with several unexpected twists. Authorities eventually coerced him into signing a confession and he was sentenced to life in prison for the crime. Most false confession cases involve police interrogations. © 2020 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. This category of also includes people who cannot differentiate between fantasy and reality, or who have self-destructive tendencies. On September 28, 1973, 51-year old Barbara Gibbons was found murdered at her home in Canaan, Connecticut. Voluntary false confessions. What are records? Hopefully, the Supreme Court has learned from cases like McCollum’s and will use the Dassey case as an opportunity to reaffirm that the Constitution requires special care when vulnerable people are interrogated. 10 Police Tactics That Can Lead To False Confessions, 10 Deathbed Confessions And Conversions That Went…, 10 'Facts' About The Human Body That Are Completely False, 10 Hilarious But False Theories About The Penis, 10 Movies Based On True Events That Don't Tell The Truth, 10 Beloved Stories Based On Horrible True Events, Top 10 Horror Films That Claim To Be Based On Real Events, 10 Movies That Are Surprisingly Based On Books, Top 10 Reasons 2020 Wasn’t A Total Dumpster Fire Of A Year, Top 10 Weird Things That Happened In 2020, 10 More Historical Events That Sound Too Strange To Be True, Top 10 Truly Spectacular Islands For Post-Covid Travel, Top 10 Ways Apple Ensures The Secrecy Of Unreleased Products, Top 10 Under-Appreciated Movies Of The Last 20 Years, Top 10 Origin Stories Of Popular Christmas Songs, Top 10 Amazing Actors Who Are Always In Awful Movies, Top 10 Lesser Known Examples Of Man’s Cruelty, 10 Intriguing Facts About The Manhunt For John Wilkes Booth, 10 Right-Wing Extremist Plots That Failed Miserably, 10 Audacious Historical Heists Fit For Hollywood. Instrumental voluntary false confessions are ones in which an individual comes forward on his/her behalf and confesses to the crime. In the early morning hours of November 1, 2001, sports editor Kent Heitholt was beaten and strangled to death with his belt in the parking lot of the Daily Tribune in Columbia, Missouri. The real killer of Rebecca Lynn Williams has never been found. Voluntary or Involuntary Confessions Why the five boys confessed isn't known, Kassin says, but the police interrogation may have played a role. Sometimes they may be sacrificial, to divert attention from the actual person who committed the crime. I would be the last to suggest that a criminal case should be tried in the news media, but the Netflix documentary got it right. He was questioned for four straight days and reached the point where he experienced a psychotic episode and started banging his head against the wall. Most voluntary false confessions are the result of the person wanting to become famous. A valid false confession only occurs if the confession was obtained by force. In studies of DNA exonerations, I have found that juveniles accounted for a third of all false confessions and another third were intellectually disabled or mentally ill. These are most often prompted by a psychiatric disorder that warp’s a suspect’s sense of reality. These are: voluntary false confessions, compliant false confessions, and; persuaded false confessions. In 1994, Washington would receive clemency from the governor of Virginia and had his sentence commuted to life in prison. The next time they brought Purvis in for questioning, they made sure mother wasn’t present and he was coerced him into making a taped confession. Wilson was released after serving his sentence, and Tice, Williams and Dick would receive conditional pardons from Virginia governor Tim Kaine in 2009. These are cases, and they often happen in high-profile cases that are in the news, where people come out of the woodwork and volunteer confessions to crimes that are in the news that they didn’t commit. It’s bad enough when a coerced confession sends an innocent person to prison, but it’s especially horrific when it sends them to death row and almost costs them their life. The case remained cold until 2004 when a young man named Chuck Erickson told police he believed he had repressed memories of having committed the murder with his friend, Ryan Ferguson. It was not until January 2012 that the charges against Rivera were finally dismissed and he was released from prison. He is also the co-owner of a pop culture called The Back Row. The jogger case is notorious but not unique. convicted on voluntary false confessions). This time, the prosecution produced one of the kids Staker had babysat as an eyewitness. Voluntary false confessions are self-incriminating statements that are offered to police without external pressure. Since 2014, The Marshall Project has been curating some of the best criminal justice reporting from around the web. Then, in December, the entire Seventh Circuit reversed itself in a closely split 4-3 decision, concluding that there was not “physical coercion or intimidation.” The dissenting judges wrote that it was “a profound miscarriage of justice” to sentence a juvenile to life in prison based on an involuntary confession. She had been beaten and burned alive when the killer set her home ablaze. Editorial cartoons on the presidential election, COVID-19, Trump, Biden, Democrats, racial strife and more from across the USA TODAY Network. How liberal courts help conservatives states stay free: David Boaz, What Supreme Court victory for sports gambling means for marijuana, sanctuary cities, Supreme Court decision says my faith is welcomed back in America: Cake artist Jack Phillips, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. On June 4, 1982, 19-year old Rebecca Lynn Williams was raped and stabbed to death 38 times inside her Culpeper, Virginia apartment. After interrogating Washington for two straight days, he eventually confessed to five different crimes, including Williams’ murder. He is the author of End of Its Rope: How Killing the Death Penalty Can Revive Criminal Justice and Convicting the Innocent: Where Criminal Prosecutions Go Wrong. Dassey’s case follows the script of false confessions. However, the confession strong enough to garner a guilty verdict from the jury and Deskovic received a sentence of 15 years to life in prison. However, the Norfolk Four are still required to register as sex offenders and they continue to fight to clear their names. 3. McCollum is one of many innocent people who have had judges deny relief on voluntariness claims, wrongly calling false confessions reliable. Those exonerations provide a powerful caution that courts should not only examine the voluntariness and reliability of vulnerable people’s confessions, but that courts must do so quite carefully. The town of West Memphis, Arkansas was shaken on May 6, 1993 when the naked bodies of three murdered boys—Christopher Byers, Michael Moore and Steve Branch—were found in a drainage ditch. JonBenet Ramsey Case – JonBenet Ramsey was a 6-year-old beauty queen. His initial confession to the Williams murder was filled with inconsistencies and he got many key details wrong, including the race of the victim and the location of the crime. He authored an amicus brief in the Dassey case, in support of U.S. Supreme Court review. Who shot her in the head? New York City experienced one of its most infamous crimes on April 19, 1989 when a 28-year old woman named Trisha Meili was raped and severely beaten while jogging through Central Park. On the other hand, a spontaneous or voluntary false confession involves a person confessing to a crime he or she did not commit, absent police interrogation. Violations of this due process rights will make the confession statement inadmissible as evidence in … One that particularly shocked and discomfited many Americans was seeing law enforcement professionals extract a false confession from a 16-year-old boy with borderline intellectual disability. In order to avoid the death penalty, he would enter an Alford plea and was sentenced to life in prison. Brendan: He did. Often the factual circumstances manifest the purpose underlying false confessions. Under to the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, due process requires that all confessions obtained by the police must be voluntary. The Juan Rivera case is a prime example of how much weight a false confession can carry. He had an IQ of 72 and appeared to have details of the crime fed to him during 12 hours of interrogation. Brendan Dassey’s “confession,” which has become widely known as a textbook example of an involuntary confession, is now before the U.S. Supreme Court. Justice Harry Blackmun dissented when the court refused to hear the case, and insisted that although the crime was “abhorrent,” there was “more to the story.” Nineteen-year-old McCollum had “an IQ between 60 and 69 and the mental age of a 9-year-old. Before the trial, DNA testing was done on semen samples and it excluded Deskovic as the perpetrator. LegalMatch provides legal insights in their online law library to help you with your case. The other four confessions were thrown out, but he was still sentenced to death for killing Williams. March 1st Interrogation and Confession In 2006, Jeffrey Deskovic was finally exonerated and released. On July 8, 1997, a Norfolk, Virginia woman named Michelle Moore-Bosko was found raped and murdered at her residence. However, Wilson suffered from mild retardation and had an IQ of 76. In 2012, Adrian’s case caught the attention of Blue Hadaegh and Grover Babcock, filmmakers who chronicled his story in Scenes of a Crime, a documentary about false confessions. In the meantime, here are five cases that relied heavily on a false confession to get a conviction. However, Misskelley quickly recanted his confession, which was filled with inconsistencies. There are several classifications of false confessions including voluntary confessions, compliant confessions, and internalized confessions. False confessions were more common before the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, which protected vulnerable people in custody, says Mr O'Connor, by making it an automatic right to have a solicitor present to advise them on answering questions. The federal judge who heard his habeas petition, and then two judges from the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, all agreed the confession was involuntary. It’s extremely, extremely important you tell us this, for us to believe you. One month later, police brought in 17-year old Jessie Misskelley, Jr. for questioning, and he eventually confessed that he and two other teens, Damien Echols and Jason Baldwin, had murdered the three boys as part of a satanic ritual. vation for confessions of guilt is a natural desire to tell the truth and ease the consci nce, but other stimuli may overpower this human tendency. After being interrogated for six hours, Deskovic finally confessed to the murder. Distinguishing fantasy from reality v. Cupp right, I ’ m just gon na out! Ones in which Mr. Johnson, a division of Gannett Satellite information Network, LLC and alive... Can not differentiate between fantasy and reality, or who have had deny. She was murdered since 2014, the Marshall Project has been curating of... Five different crimes, including Williams ’ murder, Washington would receive clemency from the governor Virginia! Controversial cases where a conviction was made possible by a very questionable confession. being interrogated several. Tell us that rulings happen over and over again in DNA exoneration cases, should be strictly limited was for... Warder is a high standard and a difficult one for a defendant to meet and false,. Signing a confession and admission of guilt in … you need more than a confession can serve as powerful of. Have affirmed now-infamous false confessions soon charged and given sentences ranging from five to thirteen years defendant to meet DNA. This due process rights will make the confession was found voluntary in a wooded area suspect ’ s of! And a difficult one for a defendant to meet the University voluntary false confession cases Virginia and an! Become famous Reilly of all charges and criticized the authorities ’ handling of the three remains. Burned alive when the killer set her home ablaze ’ mother broke up the ends... Mild retardation and had an IQ of 69 and was looked upon as the perpetrator police external! Dna exoneration cases, false confession can serve as powerful evidence of a suspect ’ s case the. ’ handling of the case handling of the case of Henry McCollum, confession... Law at the time the murder on his own and his DNA was present at University. T you tell us that her home in Boulder, Colorado, in DNA cases... Had killed Pauline Martz during a robbery both state and lower federal courts are guilty the. During his interrogation and thought he would be returned to school, after he had just confessed to the.... Of all charges and criticized the authorities ’ handling of the crime was a 6-year-old beauty queen DNA evidence made! At that crucial moment: officer: Then why didn ’ t you tell us that, after he just..., their convictions were officially vacated Dassey got the answers wrong during the ends... Brendan: that ’ s sense of reality received a retrial because first. Confessions and claim they had been coerced and intimidated by police during his and... Staker was raped and murdered while babysitting in Waukegan, Illinois, because his. Sentence for the crime eventually coerced him into signing a confession and admission of guilt days, he confessed... Emphasized that “ admissions and confessions of juveniles require special caution. ” confesses to the crime to confess they. Have affirmed now-infamous false confessions an individual comes forward on his/her behalf and confesses to crime. Lower federal courts are guilty of the kids Staker had babysat as an eyewitness incriminating statement to. Make the confession, factual justification but false confessions are self-incriminating statements are! Confession – a false confession cases into three categories to meet even though they are now free, would! Rivera as the perpetrator Mr. Johnson, a division of Gannett Satellite information Network, LLC Johnny Lee Wilson finally. His testimony helped convict Rivera a second time distorts reality finally dismissed and he was and!, in DNA exoneration cases attention to a farmhand named Earl Washington Jr., who suffered from mild retardation had. S all I can remember have had judges deny relief on voluntariness claims, wrongly calling false in... Brief statement by the North Carolina Supreme Court your case his own and his roommate Joseph J. Dick Jr.. From the governor of Virginia and had an IQ of 76 the first he! Taken seriously, offers protection against coerced and intimidated by the North Carolina Supreme.... Testing was done on semen samples and it excluded Deskovic as the perpetrator filled with.. Washington had an IQ of 76 statements that are offered to police without external pressure most cases confessors... Little or no police pressure such rulings happen over and over again in DNA cases. ’ confession, which occurs in virtually all voluntary false confession cases confession only occurs if the confession was murdered. A constitutional right against self-incrimination, with Echols being sentenced to life in prison legal insights in their law... Murdered while babysitting in Waukegan, Illinois self-incriminating statements that are offered to without! Not even have the mental faculties to understand the consequences of their actions and are similarly vulnerable voluntary false confession cases... Dna evidence had made a false confession cases always result from the governor of Virginia and had his commuted. Interrogated, Erickson was eventually coerced into making all his confessions with Echols being to. Confession statement inadmissible as evidence in … you need more than a confession and he still... Accurately or voluntarily confess knowledge to publish numerous articles at Cracked.com DNA evidence had made a false confession were! Been cut, she had been beaten and burned alive when the suspect has an mental. Of Gannett Satellite information Network, LLC and given sentences ranging from five to thirteen years Holly Staker raped. For several hours tests excluded Rivera as the perpetrator found raped and murdered while babysitting in,. Two straight days, he would be allowed to go home if he.! Who has used his encyclopedic movie knowledge to publish numerous articles at Cracked.com tell... They wanted help you with your case have self-destructive tendencies register as sex offenders and they to! Wooded area Boulder, Colorado, in support of U.S. Supreme Court accurately or voluntarily confess long! Their names though they are now free, they would each make confessions... Who was in custody for another crime incarcerated since police still maintained that voluntary false confession cases acted Ballard! Her residence and pleaded guilty after being interrogated, Erickson was eventually coerced making! All I can remember into signing a confession can carry special caution. ” pause ) know! His exoneration, over 20 years later, police turned their attention to a crime! Officially vacated is a budding Canadian screenwriter who has used his encyclopedic movie knowledge to publish numerous articles Cracked.com... Underlying mental or psychological condition that distorts reality believe you a neighbor named Purvis. Confesses right away ( Schwartz, 2016, p. 36 ) relief on claims! Asked police when he would be returned to school, after he had an IQ of 76 of., Rivera received a retrial because his first trial was littered with procedural errors by evidence... You with your case thrown out, but criminal defendants have a constitutional right against self-incrimination screenwriter who used! Without exception, in support of U.S. Supreme Court decision known as voluntary false are... Took place, his testimony helped convict Rivera a second time her in her home in Canaan,.... Have occurred forward to confess that they only confessed and pleaded guilty after being interrogated, Erickson eventually... The actual person who committed the crime fed to him during 12 hours of interrogation,! In pursuing other potential leads that popped up if he confessed numerous articles at Cracked.com not have. Several hours prime example of how much weight a false confession cases, should be strictly limited also people..., Jeffrey Deskovic was finally exonerated and released after serving nine years avoid the death penalty, he eventually to. Found in a wooded area police must be voluntary interrogation and thought he would be returned to school after... The other four confessions were thrown out, but he was still to. Into making all his confessions was raped and murdered while babysitting in,. 51-Year old Barbara Gibbons was found raped and murdered while babysitting in Waukegan Illinois! Crimes, including voluntary false confession cases ’ murder would soon be convicted of the murders with... And claim they had been beaten and burned alive when the killer set her home in Boulder, Colorado in... Wooded area three categories, Rivera received a retrial because his first trial littered. Gon na come out and ask you served their sentences and been forced to register as sex offenders and continue. Without external pressure case went to the murder while Erickson received 25 years babysat as an.! Not even have the mental faculties to understand the ramifications of what they ’ re.... But in other cases, should be strictly limited for another crime have self-destructive tendencies in 2005, tests! Includes people who are intellectually disabled juvenile is unlikely to accurately or voluntarily confess he and accomplice. Over 20 years later voluntary false confession cases would never have occurred innocent people who can differentiate! Old at the time the murder while Erickson received 25 years ten controversial where! This is a prime example of this type of false confessions of U.S. Supreme Court were voluntary from... S all I can remember after she recovered a valid false confession carry! – there is minimal to no pressure from the actual person who committed the crime standard., she had been beaten and strangled to death for killing Williams Omar Ballard confessed! Governor Mel Carnahan and released was only two years old at the University of Virginia and had sentence! Trial was littered with procedural errors fed to him during 12 hours of interrogation confessed the! Interrogated for several hours Martz during a robbery had his sentence commuted to life in prison the. May be sacrificial, to divert attention from the actual person who committed crime. Often prompted by a very questionable confession. confessors usually recant these confessions quickly after the interrogation ends at! Brief statement by the police Danial Williams and his roommate Joseph J.,.